Startup To Scale
Startup To Scale
293. Could a Product Recall Bankrupt Your CPG Brand?
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
What happens when a product recall puts your customers and your business at risk?
In this episode, I sit down with Russ Taylor from SecureCPG to discuss the recent Once Upon a Farm recall and what CPG founders can learn from it. We break down the difference between product liability and recall insurance, the hidden costs of recalls, and how brands can protect themselves financially while putting consumer safety first.
Startup to Scale is a podcast by Foodbevy, an online community to connect emerging food, beverage, and CPG founders to great resources and partners to grow their business. Visit us at Foodbevy.com to learn about becoming a member or an industry partner today.
Jordan Buckner (00:00)
The other day I woke up to a really interesting and slightly concerning email where the FDA recently warned consumers not to buy or serve once upon a farm's tractor wheeled toddler snack bars. this is following reports of a serious choking incidents that have happened. And I'll say like my family has bought these tractor wheels and you know, we like them for the most part, but I can see what they mean. And to read from the FDA's
statement, the risk of the product is that, the FDA received several reports that describe toddlers, one and a half to two and a half year olds suffering complete airway obstruction with the inability to breathe after consuming the product. When chewed, the product reportedly forms a dry, sticky mass that standard choking interventions, including back blows and high maneuvers, may fail to dislodge. So that's quote from the FDA site and it brings up this really
concerning thing, right? It's a scary situation, especially when you're talking about products designed for young kids. And it's the kind of situation that could happen to a brand regardless of how much care goes into developing its products. And so I got an email from Once Upon a Farm because I bought it through Costco and they said they're doing a voluntary kind of national nationwide recall the product. And this can be a really interesting kind of situation from the business side because
what do you do when something goes wrong and how do you make the right decisions for your customers while also making sure to protect the company you've spent years building? So I want to kind of dive into this. I have invited on Russ Taylor from SecureCPG to help me unpack kind of what's happening, what we can learn from it while being prepared for unexpected challenges. Russ, welcome back to the podcast today.
Russ (01:41)
Thanks so much for having me, Jordan.
Jordan Buckner (01:43)
So I want you on because right, the Once Upon the Farm story caught my attention. And it's not every day that we see a product recall involving a potential choking hazard just from like the product itself, especially from a brand that's so well known in the in the industry. And so, you know, I'm kind of curious like what's your initial reaction to the story and you know, some of the things you've seen with recalls are happening these days.
Russ (02:05)
Yeah, recalls are way more prevalent than people realize first and foremost.
Right, the number has gone up year over year. and you there's data that's publicly available, but yeah, I work with companies that provide recall policies on a daily basis, so I hear about a lot of the things that are happening. first point that I want to mention is that recalls can be voluntary or mandatory, and the policy responds as long as you can prove that there's potential for bodily injury or property In the case of once upon a farm,
Clearly, a choking hazard shows that there's a uh bodily injury possible. And so the policy I would expect to trigger there. When you see something like this, no company intends to have their product harm someone, is you know, the general understanding. And rigorous testing, I'm sure, happened on this product and many, many other products that have gone through recalls. But when we see something like this happen, right, what you're looking
For is the uh evidence of bodily injury occurring or the potential to occur. So, you know, uh people emailing the company and saying, hey, this happened to a family member of ours. That's going to allow the company to report that to their insurance company and say, hey, look, this is why we're going to need to institute a recall. And it's really, really an interesting vantage point when you're looking at it where you say, okay, this.
This is what's happening. it could cut, you know, the company could have issued this or they could have gotten a mandate from a governmental agency, as I mentioned earlier. and the policy should trigger because of the apparent bodily injury. So really a good use of a recall policy here, and you know, one of the reasons that you buy a recall policy.
Jordan Buckner (03:46)
Yeah, something I've been thinking about, especially as we work with lots of emerging founders, is that they don't always have the best, the right insurance setup that protects them as a CPG brand. I think one thing that the insurance industry has done, which is helpful, is a brand like business insurance, is like one set of policies that can protect a brand. but it's so generalized that when you get into situations like this and like a product recall insurance, it gets really dumb.
Because maybe it's not someone directly got hurt, but you want to prevent other things from happening. And so like would something like this per your general insurance protect you if you don't have a specific product recall insurance?
Russ (04:28)
Really good question. So if you just buy business insurance, right, the as it's branded to the the public really, that is general liability and product liability.
What that is doing is protecting against the occurrence of bodily injury or property damage. The way I like to think about recall or help brands conceptualize it is it's the precursor to the event actually happening. So you realize there's something wrong with the product, whether that's there's a contaminant in the product or there is a mislabeling of the ingredients that could you know present an allergen exposure.
you realize this and you go, my gosh, we have X amount of this product in a warehouse or on store shelves or in customers' pantries. We need to get this out of circulation so that no one actually gets hurt from this. And an interesting point, Jordan, about that is you mentioned that you got an email from Costco or Once Upon a Farm. ah
Jordan Buckner (05:30)
In both, actually.
Russ (05:31)
Yeah,
which is which is great, right? They're doing what they're supposed to be doing, right, in this instance. And one of the things about a true recall policy is let's say you have to hire a PR form to put together that statement in that campaign to get it out to the general public or to your consumers, those dollars can be found and utilized from a recall policy. There's numerous things that a recall policy can can provide dollars of protection for. But to summarize your your question, right, you're
Initial business insurance is just the occurrence of bodily injury or property damage. So it would not cover the cost associated with the recall. It would cover the costs associated with medical bills or damage to or injury to a person that has bought your product. If you wanted to pay to get the product off the shelf and dispose of it, that would be a recall policy, which is a separate policy.
Jordan Buckner (06:26)
Awesome. No, that's really helpful because I think
A lot of founders don't quite realize exactly what their plans cover, why or when. And if this happens to you, right, you need to be able to make a decision within, same day or next day. And it's important to know what coverage you have and and how it does that. You know, something I've been thinking about this is the founder perspective, when you've got consumers potentially at risk, retailers are expecting answers, and it's gonna make a massive financial impact on your business, you need the right information and to make a clear decision.
That's going to support consumers, protect them, while also not feeling like your business could collapse from it, right? Because I know lots of businesses who have this happened to them on a smaller scale and they did not have recall insurance, their entire business could collapse.
Russ (07:12)
Yeah, it so recall policies in modern CPG function in a couple different ways.
The one I would say is most prevalent that I get asked about is we're a CVG brand. We make potato chips, but we don't actually make them, right? Our co-packer or our co-manufacturer in Idaho makes the potato chips for us and they put them in the bags and they ship them out to the stores. You know, Russ, we don't touch any of this. I go, that's great, but your name's still on the label. So if somebody gets hurt by them or realizes there's something wrong with them, you have, you know, your branding is everywhere. They're gonna reach out to you.
They don't know who your co-packer is. So a lot of times what the insurance policy, the recall insurance policy is doing is absorbing cost until you can figure out who's actually at fault. Right? You need to get a statement out. You need to start pulling boxes of product and disposing of it or do an investigation. Again.
Of the litany of things that recall policies can cover. Investigation costs is one, oh disposal of product is another. That's what the policy is doing, is absorbing cost, legal defense, as you're investigating and trying to figure out who is actually at fault and whose insurance should actually respond.
Jordan Buckner (08:30)
Yeah, and you mentioned a good point
with
a lot of people using co-manufacturers to make their products. W as a brand, what should you ensure is in place with your co-manufacturers so that if there is an issue, they are more likely to have coverage. Of course, they would not want they're probably gonna fight you on being at fault. I've seen that happen a lot. but tell me about like what that what that happens and what a brand can do to protect themselves when working with a co manufacturer.
Russ (09:00)
Yeah, and I don't want to paint this as big, bad, big, bad co-man ink, but the co-men are are usually looking at the brands and saying, well, this is kind of your fault. And everyone starts pointing fingers in the event of a, you know, an incident or a claim. One thing I I really strongly advise our brands to do is when they're working with a co-packer or co-manufacturer, is you know, be listed as additional insured and and when you're looking through that contract,
Try and figure out if they have recall insurance. It's really nice. Not every co-packer has recall insurance, and not every brand has the leverage to ask them to carry recall insurance for them. The bigger the brand, the bigger the manufacturer, the more likely there's an agreement in place that has recall involved. And just because your co-packer has recall insurance does not mean that you as the brand should not carry recall insurance, right? If you're a lot of times I hear, well, my co-packer has recall insurance.
So go, that's great. And it sounds like you're working with a really reputable co-packer, but they're not the ones that are going to get served a lawsuit if you know, the brand on the shelf impacts someone's daily life, right? That's where your recall policy will step in and absorb cost and deflect and protect the brand. While again, you do an investigation and figure out was this a an issue on the uh packaging side? Was this an issue on the manufacturing side?
supplier side, a lot of the recalls that we've dealt with, it comes through the copacker to the brand and say, you know, our provider provided a tainted product or tainted ingredient of some sort. So the copacker wasn't even really at fault, right? They sourced an ingredient from someone and the ingredient was at fault. so
What we're looking at here is you you're trying to have a airtight contract and you'd like every party involved to have recall coverage if possible.
Jordan Buckner (10:50)
Yeah, one of my takeaways from this story as well is that it doesn't necessarily take a manufacturing mistake or a contamination issue to have a serious problem. And so I'm kind of curious, are there categories, especially children's food, where risks are fundamentally different with the product?
Russ (11:09)
Yeah, and it's the companies in those areas are probably gonna be aware of it, right? C B D and THC,
Products for toddlers, infants, babies, supplement and things that are not as strictly regulated as food are typically more strongly underwritten or more closely scrutinized when you're looking at a recall policy, because it's the same way for a liability policy, right? Infants and kids, Jordan, I know both you and I have young kids, you know, we're hyper aware of what we're giving to our kids, allowing them to have.
Eat, play with. So it's, you know, if you're a parent, right, if you are suspect about the practice of giving your kid, you can probably lump that into the tougher on the underwriting side to get a policy for. One area, Jordan, I I want to mention, and it steps outside the normal bounds.
Of what traditional recall has looked like for the last, I don't know, 20, 25 years. We started pushing back on the recall industry, the recall underwriters, you know, probably two years ago.
And one of the things that we kept saying was we're seeing a lot of issues on the product side that are non harmful, but it's still a defective product, right? The taste, the aroma, or the appearance is off. and a couple of examples that I've seen over the last few months to years are, you know, vitamins that are in gel or gummy form and they all congeal together into into one giant gummy within the
the package or you know a beverage that's supposed to taste one flavor and it comes out tasting sour or
Different product, or I've seen green juices or green beverages that come out kind of brown or orange better. It's not going to harm anyone, but it's you know called a uh green juice or green beverage of some sort. So nobody's gonna buy it if it's brown or orange. And so a new endorsement that's available to the CPG marketplace is it's called a quality defect endorsement. And so as I mentioned earlier, right, the normal trigger for
A recall policy is potential for bodily injury or property damage. This is a sublimit that you can get added onto the policy for additional premium, and it triggers if the product quality is defective, but not necessarily harmful. It doesn't give you as robust a coverage and you don't get full policy limits, but we've still seen it where if you buy a million-dollar policy, they give you about a hundred thousand dollar limit, and that might save you a production run.
Jordan Buckner (13:46)
Yeah, I think that's
really insightful because what do you do if you're a brand you know you have product that's not the best that's going out in the market. And if you pull that back, that's product that you can't otherwise recover, the inventory costs. And so I love that as an option, especially for brands who are increasing scales. They're maybe working
Russ (14:06)
Yeah.
Jordan Buckner (14:07)
with a new manufacturer who though they haven't worked with before, but they have to do a large order for like a Costco or someone, right? Like this can give you that protection that
Otherwise you wouldn't have.
Russ (14:18)
Yeah, that's 100% where we see the majority of these happen is either new co-packer relationship or increased production size, right? You're used to doing a $25,000 to $50,000 production run. You get into national distribution with someone and you increase to $100,000, $200,000 production runs, and something gets off slightly by one or two percent, and
The product is not otherwise harmful, but it's basically not sellable in the format that it is, or it'll do potential brand harm or reputational reputational harm.
Jordan Buckner (14:53)
That's so helpful. Once upon a farm is a sizable company, but imagine this happening to a brand doing two million dollars in sales. Could a single product recall bankrupt a small company?
Russ (15:05)
Absolutely. you know, you hope you never see that. and there's with brands as large as Once Upon a Farm, you know, they have very robust insurance policies, I'm sure. we work with several brands that are in the multiple tens and hundreds of millions, and their recall policies, you know, look rather large and are very expensive. We work with companies specifically in the you know the one to ten to twenty million range on
getting them the right size for their recall policy because we have seen brands that call us after an incident that they want to recall and they don't have recall insurance and they're trying to figure out what their options are and it's gonna, you know, they might be doing three or four million in sales and they're facing a half a million to a million dollar recall once all of the costs are considered. Again, you have the we need to pull it off the shelf, we need to dispose of it, we need to remake it.
But there's also the potential legal, potential third party fees that are associated with. So there's a lot of soft costs that go into recall as well. But one thing that we've worked closely with our recall underwriters on is helping
Emerging and scaling brands find a recall policy that's affordable for them and at the right size. So option sizes have really become way better for recall where there's now recall limits as low as $100,000 available, and they start at a much more affordable price between two and three thousand dollars in premium for the year. And you can get you can also get an increment of $250,000 in limit, a half a million dollars in limit, and then beyond that, it's really
It increases by a million dollars in steps.
We again and I'm sure other agents were approaching the marketplace saying we need an option for these brands in the one to five million range that isn't gonna cost them ten thousand dollars in premium, but they need recall coverage. And I I strongly encourage brands that are in the the scaling phase to look at a recall policy. Anecdotally, we s probably sixty seventy percent.
percent of claims that we handle are recall in nature. And I think that is is really gives you two data points if you're a brand founder or operator listening to this is they happen fairly frequently.
And food safety is still doing pretty good at catching stuff before someone actually gets hurt. And that's the whole point of the recall is we don't want someone to get hurt and no brand wants someone to get hurt from their product. So the ability to have this policy and then pull the product out of the marketplace before something actually happens is unbelievably important.
Jordan Buckner (17:45)
Once Upon the Farm also has many product lines. So what happens to a food brand's business when their primary product has a product recall?
Russ (17:55)
So when you're looking at a recall for a brand that has 10, 20, 30, 40 SKUs, we're providing that information to the recall underwriter. For a small brand, they might have, you know, a handful of they might have one product with a handful of flavors, so it's not looking totally different. Umce upon a farm,
and other brands that have, you know, multiple different product lines. you're providing all of the product lines with the ingredients to the underwriter or on the application so that they can assess the risk of each of those before they provide a policy with, you know, quoted premiums.
Jordan Buckner (18:39)
And then if you have to pull your primary product off the market, what are some of those other costs that could be associated with that happening, right? I'm thinking inventory being not available to continue selling. You mentioned PR costs as well. And maybe, revenue and sales for that business can decrease for a period of time. Are there any other things that you've seen happen?
Russ (19:04)
Yeah, the the cost to remake the product, remanufacture it, can be covered. and then
If you get hit with fees from your vendors or retailers, the third-party damages can be covered by by recall. legal fees if you get dragged into litigation surrounding the recall, that can be covered by recall policy. There's a numerous there's numerous things, and each insurance company that provides a recall policy has a couple different bells and whistles that they fold in to try and make their policy more appealing.
But it really is an extremely robust policy, where a lot of times when I have conversations with brand owners and founders and having the discussion on how are we going ensure the business and what lines of coverage do we need, I'm talking about property is kind of an asilo, right? It covers the inventory from being damaged or stolen or destroyed. general liability and product liability protect from you know the operations or the consumption.
the product, and there's a maybe some other stuff included in there. Recall, because it's usually a precursor, and you're showing hey, there's a potential for bodily injury or property damage. People may be aware of the the Chomps recall where there was metal shavings in the product. we're looking at where hey, could someone be hurt by this? The insurance companies realize that there's a lot of moving parts to a recall, and there's a lot of unknowns, and because
there's so many different things that go into a recall, they have built the policy such that there's eight or nine different coverage options on there where you could incur expenses going through a recall.
Jordan Buckner (20:39)
That's super helpful. Russ, thanks so much for being on today and discussing what happened with Once Upon the Farm and also for emerging brands. protect yourself from this happening to you so that you can do right by the consumer and make sure your business moves forward. If you need help finding insurance or understanding what needs coverage as a food or beverage CPG brand, definitely reach out to Secure CPG. They're our sponsor for today's episode so that you can make sure that you are covered. let me know. You can send me an email, reach out through their website and get a quote today. Thanks everyone.